This is the complete naturally generated transcript for the uninterrupted live governed run. It is not a release summary.
# Agent Control Natural Execution Transcript > Product-generated during execution from authoritative durable records. This is not an after-the-fact narrative and excludes credentials, raw provider transport payloads, and private chain-of-thought. ## Origin - Channel: `dashboard` - Modality: `dashboard` - Received: `2026-09-09T07:04:50.202Z` - Authentication: `operator-token` - Governed actor: `web-operator` - Authority: `parcel.create` - Identity reference: `d321dbf1aae2c81956d001d280043aff0f826b634a436c62a627ad74e161646a` - Message/audio reference: `c8f68d5470dfe044546a1920bd16a9be58a6dc068e05b2f19193f37284fcf846` ## Authoritative initiating request > Complete the read-only review of the frozen reservation-service fixture on the authorised qualification branch. Explain whether concurrent callers can both acquire the same resource and whether expired cache entries can be accepted as fresh. Preserve evidence, use the configured quality gate, and escalate only if the first route misses either root cause. origin/main must remain completely unchanged. Do not deploy production. Verify the result. - Schema: `agent-control.execution-transcript/v1` - Job Run: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050` - Saved Job: `crew-wopr-quality-review` - Job: Crew/WOPR quality-escalation review - Status: `SUCCEEDED_WITH_FINDINGS` - Execution mode: `LIVE` — live/real execution - Work Parcels: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Source retention: complete-durable; uncapped=yes ## Chronological execution record ### 0001 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.098Z · JOB_REQUEST - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:requested` - Actor: OPERATOR - Outcome: `INFO` **Crew/WOPR quality-escalation review requested** > Review a frozen Git revision and produce evidence-backed, validated findings. Scope full; requested ref 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020. ### 0002 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.098Z · OPERATOR_OBJECTIVE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:operator-objective` - Actor: OPERATOR - Outcome: `INFO` **Exact governed review instruction** > You are performing a governed, read-only repository review. > Use only the supplied frozen-revision evidence and context. Find correctness, reliability, security, and maintainability defects. Distinguish proven defects from concerns. Cite real file paths and line ranges. Do not invent paths, symbols, test results, or execution evidence. Do not request or perform source modification. > Treat repository tests and documented invariants as acceptance evidence. Return only the JSON object governed by the supplied output schema, with no markdown or commentary. Set schema to agent-control.repository-review/v1. Verdict must be PASS, PASS_WITH_FINDINGS, REVIEW_REQUIRED, or FAILED. A completed review with supported defects is PASS_WITH_FINDINGS, regardless of severity; FAILED means the review itself could not be completed or could not produce a usable result. Use null for file/startLine/endLine only for genuinely repository-level findings. Express confidence as a decimal from 0 through 1, never as a percentage. Every finding begins with validation state UNVERIFIED; independent Agent Control validation owns acceptance. Use PASS only when this supplied chunk has no supported finding. ### 0003 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.098Z · JOB_QUEUED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:transition:2026-09-09T07:05:02.098Z:QUEUED` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` **Job queued** > Awaiting the governed scheduler. ### 0004 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z · JOB_RESOLVING - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:transition:2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z:RESOLVING` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` **Resolving immutable target and route** > Resolving the immutable repository revision, execution node, provider route, and bounded context. ### 0005 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z · REPOSITORY_SNAPSHOT - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:repository` - Actor: TOOL / ACTION - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` **Immutable repository revision resolved** > reservation-service-fixture at 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020; requested ref 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020; snapshot clean. - Evidence: `2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020` ### 0006 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z · CONTEXT_COMPILED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:context` - Actor: TOOL / ACTION - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` **THIN review context compiled** > 1 bounded chunk(s), 5 file(s), 0 omitted file(s). Provider input is represented by the governed instruction and frozen context manifest; raw repository context is not duplicated into transcript storage. - Evidence: `1f6ffbfee231e2c088844f597a482bb6e13368c67bbba6336e3669fded39566c` ### 0007 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z · ROUTE_SELECTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:route` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Governed provider route selected** > local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller. Route purpose EXECUTION; qualification evidence live-llama-cpp-preflight-v1; initial route fallback no. ### 0008 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.106Z · PROVIDER_REQUEST - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:provider-request` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `INFO` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Read-only structured review requested** > You are performing a governed, read-only repository review. Input used 1 frozen context chunk(s). Credentials, environment values, hidden reasoning, and raw prompt payloads are not retained in this human-readable projection. ### 0009 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.167Z · JOB_RUNNING - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:transition:2026-09-09T07:05:02.167Z:RUNNING` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `RUNNING` **Provider execution started** > The selected provider is executing the read-only structured review. ### 0010 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · WORK_PARCEL_CREATED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:created` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Work Parcel parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697 created** > Objective: Review frozen 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020 context chunk context-1-1f6ffbfee231 > Planner: deterministic — Repository Job deterministically decomposed frozen context > Execution owner: direct-repository-review-executor > Current durable status at transcript projection: SUCCEEDED ### 0011 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PROVENANCE_JOB-RUN - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z:job-run:15` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: job-run** > 0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050 - Evidence: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050` ### 0012 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PROVENANCE_REQUEST-ORIGIN - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z:request-origin:16` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: request-origin** > dashboard:c8f68d5470dfe044546a1920bd16a9be58a6dc068e05b2f19193f37284fcf846 - Evidence: `dashboard:c8f68d5470dfe044546a1920bd16a9be58a6dc068e05b2f19193f37284fcf846` ### 0013 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PROVENANCE_EXECUTION-MODE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z:execution-mode:17` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: execution-mode** > LIVE - Evidence: `LIVE` ### 0014 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PROVENANCE_REVIEWED-SHA - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z:reviewed-sha:18` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: reviewed-sha** > 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020 - Evidence: `2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020` ### 0015 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PROVENANCE_EXECUTION-LOCALITY - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z:execution-locality:19` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: execution-locality** > workload=controller;provider=controller;credential=none - Evidence: `workload=controller;provider=controller;credential=none` ### 0016 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PARCEL_TASK_RECEIVED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-12a5fa70-80c3-4e30-bce3-17b6413d3e61` - Actor: TOOL / ACTION - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Frozen review chunk received** > context-1-1f6ffbfee231 ### 0017 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.177Z · PARCEL_ROUTE_RESOLVED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-88905d5b-58a4-45b1-9fe2-c2c07216abf5` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **local-llama/default/qwen-local-small-reviewer@controller** > Qualification live-llama-cpp-preflight-v1; fallback false; purpose EXECUTION ### 0018 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.189Z · PROVENANCE_RETRIEVAL_FALLBACK - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:02.189Z:retrieval.fallback:20` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: retrieval.fallback** > frozen-context - Evidence: `frozen-context` ### 0019 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.189Z · PARCEL_READINESS_CHECKED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-60e06902-a294-4eb2-810b-1a311c9171a5` - Actor: TOOL / ACTION - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Governed retrieval unavailable; controlled frozen context retained** > retrieval_disabled ### 0020 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.196Z · PARCEL_INVOCATION_STARTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-eaf980cb-6c96-4fed-a1bc-401ae50a5e5c` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **local-llama/default/qwen-local-small-reviewer@controller provider invocation started** > Thread repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231; frozen context context-1-1f6ffbfee231; structured schema agent-control.repository-review/v1; invocation profile provider-default ### 0021 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.204Z · TELEMETRY_STARTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:0` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `UNAVAILABLE` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Live token measurement pending provider completion** > Initial sample: current context unavailable (provider_not_yet_reported). Lifetime usage: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: unavailable / 32,768 tokens; percentage unavailable; unavailable. - Lifetime: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0022 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.216Z · GOVERNOR_DECISION - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:governor:token-route:2fa01807-d8aa-452d-9490-0fd530c8b3b1` - Actor: GOVERNOR - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Governor CONTINUE: CONTINUE** > State CONTINUE; action CONTINUE; outcome RECORDED; reason current_context_unavailable. - Evidence: `token-route:2fa01807-d8aa-452d-9490-0fd530c8b3b1` ### 0023 · 2026-09-09T07:05:02.220Z · TELEMETRY_SAMPLE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:1` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Live telemetry sample 2** > Latest sample: current context unavailable (provider_did_not_report_current_context). Lifetime usage: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: unavailable / 32,768 tokens; percentage unavailable; unavailable. - Lifetime: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0024 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.770Z · TELEMETRY_SAMPLE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:2` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Live telemetry sample 3** > Latest sample: 1,455 / 32,768 tokens, 4.44% displayed, estimated. Lifetime usage: 773 input (1 fresh + 772 cached), 682 output, 1,455 total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: 1,455 / 32,768 tokens; 4.44%; estimated. - Lifetime: 773 input (1 fresh + 772 cached), 682 output, 1,455 total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0025 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.775Z · MODEL_INVOCATION_ACCOUNTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:invocation:sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **local-llama/qwen-local-small-reviewer invocation accounted** > Outcome stop; verifier PASS_WITH_FINDINGS; harness profile THIN; provider invocation profile provider-default; request dispatched yes; usage authority authoritative; elapsed 15,550 ms. Lifetime usage 773 input (1 fresh + 772 cached + unavailable cache write), 682 output, unavailable reasoning, 1,455 total. Provider cost unavailable; calculated cost unavailable; selected basis unavailable. - Evidence: `sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba` ### 0026 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.775Z · PROVENANCE_PROVIDER-RESPONSE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:17.775Z:provider-response:21` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: provider-response** > sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba - Evidence: `sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba` ### 0027 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.775Z · PARCEL_INVOCATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-7a74f9fd-e79e-4b3a-b367-0fca3ad856e3` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **local-llama/default/qwen-local-small-reviewer@controller returned structured review output** > Response sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba; finish stop ### 0028 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.783Z · PROVENANCE_QUALITY-GATE-FAILED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:17.783Z:quality-gate-failed:22` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `FAILED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: quality-gate-failed** > reservation-cache-root-cause-v1:sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba - Evidence: `reservation-cache-root-cause-v1:sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba` ### 0029 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.783Z · PARCEL_VERIFICATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-bc3360b9-9e67-4c3a-8b98-f997dc0f0e5c` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Independent quality gate rejected local-llama/qwen-local-small-reviewer** > reservation-cache-root-cause-v1; Schema-valid review did not satisfy 4 acceptance-level root-cause criteria.; evidence fixture:test/acceptance.test.mjs, fixture:README.md, provider-response:sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba; unresolved Identify the reservation operation as a non-atomic check-then-update sequence, explicitly or by proving both callers check before either updates ownership., Explain that both callers can observe the resource as unowned before either caller updates ownership., Identify that createdAt - now reverses the cache-age subtraction and yields a negative age for stale entries., State that cache age must be calculated as now - entry.createdAt. ### 0030 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.790Z · HANDOFF_REQUESTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:governor:token-route:eb8c4e56-fc67-4772-a574-bae7597b1c21` - Actor: GOVERNOR - Outcome: `RECOMMENDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Governed handoff requested** > State CONTINUE; action BATON_AND_HANDOFF; outcome RECORDED; reason quality_gate_failed_governed_fallback_selected:reservation-cache-root-cause-v1. A request is not proof of dispatch, acceptance, destination execution, or completion. - Evidence: `token-route:eb8c4e56-fc67-4772-a574-bae7597b1c21` ### 0031 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.795Z · BATON_CREATED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:baton:token-baton:3fa7319f-65f1-4c89-ba95-359432e1431e` - Actor: BATON - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Verified baton created and sealed** > Objective: You are performing a governed, read-only repository review. > Use only the supplied frozen-revision evidence and context. Find correctness, reliability, security, and maintainability defects. Distinguish proven defects from concerns. Cite real file paths and line ranges. Do not invent paths, symbols, test results, or execution evidence. Do not request or perform source modification. > Treat repository tests and documented invariants as acceptance evidence. Return only the JSON object governed by the supplied output schema, with no markdown or commentary. Set schema to agent-control.repository-review/v1. Verdict must be PASS, PASS_WITH_FINDINGS, REVIEW_REQUIRED, or FAILED. A completed review with supported defects is PASS_WITH_FINDINGS, regardless of severity; FAILED means the review itself could not be completed or could not produce a usable result. Use null for file/startLine/endLine only for genuinely repository-level findings. Express confidence as a decimal from 0 through 1, never as a percentage. Every finding begins with validation state UNVERIFIED; independent Agent Control validation owns acceptance. Use PASS only when this supplied chunk has no supported finding. > Frozen repository: reservation-service-fixture at 2ee7ea70fb1d09407b76cc4d8bd5c8cc5bd2f020. Next action: Using the same frozen repository and original objective, explain both failing acceptance-test root causes precisely and return a schema-valid read-only repository review.. SHA-256 aaff53edd26b3a5e7968cd78b6bdefb68332f3df80b850c6614a58efc2ca5ca6. Creation does not by itself mean dispatch, acceptance, destination execution, or completed handoff. - Evidence: `token-baton:3fa7319f-65f1-4c89-ba95-359432e1431e`, `aaff53edd26b3a5e7968cd78b6bdefb68332f3df80b850c6614a58efc2ca5ca6` ### 0032 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.801Z · HANDOFF_REQUESTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:governor:token-route:e48d1200-e66a-4957-8afb-478da0c0e5a5` - Actor: GOVERNOR - Outcome: `RECOMMENDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Governed handoff requested** > State CONTINUE; action BATON_AND_HANDOFF; outcome RECORDED; reason verified_baton_ready_for_explicit_handoff. A request is not proof of dispatch, acceptance, destination execution, or completion. - Evidence: `token-route:e48d1200-e66a-4957-8afb-478da0c0e5a5`, `token-baton:3fa7319f-65f1-4c89-ba95-359432e1431e` ### 0033 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.811Z · PARCEL_INVOCATION_STARTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-3547a4b9-67db-4bd7-a8da-65ef4456bbf1` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **codex-chatgpt/Controller Account A/codex-luna-controller-a@controller provider invocation started** > Thread repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:quality:codex-luna-controller-a; frozen context context-1-1f6ffbfee231; structured schema agent-control.repository-review/v1; invocation profile provider-default; continuation baton token-baton:3fa7319f-65f1-4c89-ba95-359432e1431e ### 0034 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.819Z · TELEMETRY_STARTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:quality:codex-luna-controller-a:0` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `UNAVAILABLE` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a @ controller - Provider/model: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a **Live token measurement pending provider completion** > Initial sample: current context unavailable (provider_not_yet_reported). Lifetime usage: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: unavailable / 272,000 tokens; percentage unavailable; unavailable. - Lifetime: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0035 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.825Z · GOVERNOR_DECISION - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:governor:token-route:e0bbdff4-65b3-41a5-9c36-128ceb6b88a1` - Actor: GOVERNOR - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a @ controller - Provider/model: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a **Governor CONTINUE: CONTINUE** > State CONTINUE; action CONTINUE; outcome RECORDED; reason current_context_unavailable. - Evidence: `token-route:e0bbdff4-65b3-41a5-9c36-128ceb6b88a1` ### 0036 · 2026-09-09T07:05:17.833Z · TELEMETRY_SAMPLE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:quality:codex-luna-controller-a:1` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a @ controller - Provider/model: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a **Live telemetry sample 2** > Latest sample: current context unavailable (codex_jsonl_does_not_report_current_context). Lifetime usage: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: unavailable / 272,000 tokens; percentage unavailable; unavailable. - Lifetime: unavailable input (unavailable fresh + unavailable cached), unavailable output, unavailable total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0037 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.443Z · TELEMETRY_SAMPLE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:telemetry:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1:context-1-1f6ffbfee231:quality:codex-luna-controller-a:2` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a @ controller - Provider/model: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a **Live telemetry sample 3** > Latest sample: current context unavailable (codex_exec_turn_usage_is_not_current_context). Lifetime usage: 8,122 input (8,122 fresh + 0 cached), 771 output, 8,893 total. Cached input remains part of total input and is not subtracted from context occupancy. Cost unavailable (unavailable). Governor CONTINUE. - Telemetry: - Current context: unavailable / 272,000 tokens; percentage unavailable; unavailable. - Lifetime: 8,122 input (8,122 fresh + 0 cached), 771 output, 8,893 total. - Cost: unavailable; unavailable. - Governor: CONTINUE. ### 0038 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.672Z · MODEL_INVOCATION_ACCOUNTED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:invocation:sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a @ controller - Provider/model: codex-chatgpt / Controller Account A / codex-luna-controller-a **codex-chatgpt/codex-luna-controller-a invocation accounted** > Outcome completed; verifier PASS_WITH_FINDINGS; harness profile THIN; provider invocation profile provider-default; request dispatched yes; usage authority authoritative; elapsed 16,839 ms. Lifetime usage 8,122 input (8,122 fresh + 0 cached + unavailable cache write), 771 output, unavailable reasoning, 8,893 total. Provider cost unavailable; calculated cost unavailable; selected basis unavailable. - Evidence: `sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` ### 0039 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.672Z · PROVENANCE_PROVIDER-RESPONSE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:34.672Z:provider-response:23` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: provider-response** > sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337 - Evidence: `sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` ### 0040 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.672Z · PARCEL_INVOCATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-722d7ca0-ab63-478b-bde4-dfbf253d10b7` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **codex-chatgpt/Controller Account A/codex-luna-controller-a@controller returned structured review output** > Response sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337; finish completed ### 0041 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.682Z · PROVENANCE_QUALITY-GATE-PASSED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:34.682Z:quality-gate-passed:24` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: quality-gate-passed** > reservation-cache-root-cause-v1:sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337 - Evidence: `reservation-cache-root-cause-v1:sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` ### 0042 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.682Z · PARCEL_VERIFICATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-139cf277-b030-442e-a7df-df511d855fb0` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Independent quality gate accepted codex-chatgpt/codex-luna-controller-a** > reservation-cache-root-cause-v1; The review proves both acceptance-test root causes: the non-atomic reservation interleaving and the reversed cache-age subtraction.; evidence fixture:test/acceptance.test.mjs, fixture:README.md, provider-response:sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337; unresolved none ### 0043 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.689Z · HANDOFF_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:governor:token-route:7885223c-961c-4ae7-8449-9b06e14a6965` - Actor: GOVERNOR - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Governed handoff completed** > State CONTINUE; action BATON_AND_HANDOFF; outcome SUCCEEDED; reason handoff_completed_original_thread_recoverable. - Evidence: `token-route:7885223c-961c-4ae7-8449-9b06e14a6965`, `token-baton:3fa7319f-65f1-4c89-ba95-359432e1431e` ### 0044 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.694Z · PROVENANCE_GOVERNED-VERIFICATION-CONTRACT - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:34.694Z:governed-verification-contract:25` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: governed-verification-contract** > contract:519cbb81-284f-4a7e-b718-202c8596a28d - Evidence: `contract:519cbb81-284f-4a7e-b718-202c8596a28d` ### 0045 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.694Z · PARCEL_ROUTE_CHANGED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-0686f8f5-c9c3-4208-a97e-5748b1915626` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Quality gate reservation-cache-root-cause-v1 selected codex-chatgpt/codex-luna-controller-a; destination passed independently** > contract:519cbb81-284f-4a7e-b718-202c8596a28d ### 0046 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.701Z · STAGE_SUCCEEDED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:stage:review` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Review context-1-1f6ffbfee231: SUCCEEDED** > Job repository-code-review@1. Dependencies: none. Required capabilities: repository-review. Requested route: provider policy-selected; account policy-selected; model qwen-local-small-reviewer; role review.default; fallback allowed; purpose EXECUTION. Actual route: provider local-llama; account default; model qwen-local-small-reviewer; workload node controller; execution node controller. ### 0047 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.701Z · PROVENANCE_PROVIDER-COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:34.701Z:provider-completed:26` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: provider-completed** > Provider local-llama; model qwen-local-small-reviewer; structured review returned - Evidence: `Provider local-llama; model qwen-local-small-reviewer; structured review returned` ### 0048 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.718Z · PROVIDER_EXECUTION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:execution:repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Route: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer @ controller - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Route-bound provider attempt 1: COMPLETED** > Execution repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1; started 2026-09-09T07:05:02.172Z; workload node controller; provider execution node controller; credential node provider default; active turn not reported. - Evidence: `repository-review:0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:1` ### 0049 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.725Z · JOB_VALIDATING - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:transition:2026-09-09T07:05:34.725Z:VALIDATING` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `RUNNING` **Independent validation started** > Agent Control is validating provider output independently. ### 0050 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.734Z · PROVENANCE_VERIFICATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697:provenance:2026-09-09T07:05:34.734Z:verification.completed:27` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `INFO` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Provenance: verification.completed** > PASS_WITH_FINDINGS - Evidence: `PASS_WITH_FINDINGS` ### 0051 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.734Z · PARCEL_VERIFICATION_COMPLETED - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:parcel:audit-a577696e-3bd6-4337-a91a-bfb03ad312e8` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Work Parcel: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` **Independent repository validation: PASS_WITH_FINDINGS** > Parameterized Job validation accepted the consolidated repository-review result ### 0052 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · JOB_SUCCEEDED_WITH_FINDINGS - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:transition:2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z:SUCCEEDED_WITH_FINDINGS` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` **Job completed with validated findings** > PASS WITH FINDINGS ### 0053 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · PROVIDER_RESPONSE - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:provider-response` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Provider output recorded** > Two acceptance invariants are violated: reservation ownership is checked before an await, allowing concurrent callers to pass the check, and cache freshness subtracts timestamps in the wrong order, making old entries appear fresh. - Evidence: `sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba`, `sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337`, `provider_response_sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba`, `provider_response_sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` ### 0054 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · VALIDATED_RESULT - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:validated-result` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` - Provider/model: local-llama / default account / qwen-local-small-reviewer **Validated repository-review result: PASS_WITH_FINDINGS** > Two acceptance invariants are violated: reservation ownership is checked before an await, allowing concurrent callers to pass the check, and cache freshness subtracts timestamps in the wrong order, making old entries appear fresh. > > Areas reviewed: README.md acceptance invariants, package.json test configuration, src/reservation-ledger.mjs, src/snapshot-cache.mjs, test/acceptance.test.mjs > Areas not reviewed: none > Positive observations: The reservation ledger uses a private Map for ownership state.; The acceptance tests directly encode both documented invariants. - Evidence: `sha256:67f3f523cb6c6fe08dfcb3c8fdd9c6c796b789ea70c8c033da76b328483363ba`, `sha256:5ccb107feb7a94759ae74f663e600b70d22e0bcbe1ddd64c231584f3803e4337` ### 0055 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · VALIDATED_FINDING - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:finding:reservation-concurrency-check-then-await` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `INFO` **HIGH — Reservation is not atomic across the audit await** > Location: src/reservation-ledger.mjs:4-8 > Category: correctness > Evidence: reserve() checks this.#owners.has(resourceId) at line 5, awaits audit() at line 6, and only records ownership at line 7. > Operational reasoning: Two concurrent calls for the same unowned resource can both evaluate the check before either call reaches the set operation. Both then await the audit callback, and both subsequently set the owner and return true. The acceptance invariant requires at most one successful acquisition; the await creates a check-then-act race. > Impact: Concurrent callers can both report successful acquisition of one resource, violating exclusivity and potentially causing duplicate work or conflicting ownership state. The later caller's owner overwrites the earlier caller's owner. > Suggested remediation: Make the check-and-claim operation atomic before any await, or otherwise serialize reservations per resource. Ensure audit failure handling preserves a clearly defined ownership invariant. > Confidence: 0.99 > Validation: VALID — no additional reasons - Evidence: `reservation-concurrency-check-then-await` ### 0056 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · VALIDATED_FINDING - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:finding:snapshot-cache-reversed-age-calculation` - Actor: AGENT / PROVIDER - Outcome: `INFO` **HIGH — Freshness calculation reverses creation time and current time** > Location: src/snapshot-cache.mjs:1-3 > Category: correctness > Evidence: isFresh() returns entry.createdAt - now < ttlMs. For the acceptance case createdAt=1000, now=10000, ttlMs=100, the computed age is -9000, which satisfies the comparison. > Operational reasoning: The documented freshness rule defines age as current time minus creation time. The implementation computes creation time minus current time, producing a negative value for normally aged entries. Consequently, an entry older than its TTL is classified as fresh instead of stale, so the supplied acceptance assertion is violated. > Impact: Expired cache entries can be served as fresh, causing stale snapshots and incorrect behavior for all callers relying on this predicate. > Suggested remediation: Compute age as now - entry.createdAt and compare that age against ttlMs, while separately deciding whether future-dated entries should be treated as fresh or invalid. > Confidence: 1 > Validation: VALID — no additional reasons - Evidence: `snapshot-cache-reversed-age-calculation` ### 0057 · 2026-09-09T07:05:34.745Z · LEDGER_RECONCILIATION - Event ID: `0694aac3-ea15-41a8-832e-f9e2236a7050:ledger` - Actor: SYSTEM EVENT - Outcome: `SUCCEEDED` **Job and Work Parcel accounting reconcile** > Job ledger: 8,895 input (8,123 fresh + 772 cached) + 1,453 output = 10,348 total; unavailable. Work Parcel ledger: 8,895 input (8,123 fresh + 772 cached) + 1,453 output = 10,348 total; unavailable. Accounted invocations 2; invocations with unavailable token usage 0. - Evidence: `parcel-816db10a-5c4a-45da-80b9-f130bdacd697` ## Integrity and scope - Entries: 57 - Ordering: timestamp, then deterministic source-projection sequence; durable event identifiers are shown for traceability. - Authority: Job Run state, Work Parcel audit/provenance, model invocation ledger, token/governor lifecycle, and sealed baton records. - Deliberately excluded: credential values, authentication material, raw rejected provider payloads, and hidden/private model reasoning. - The adjacent JSON manifest records the SHA-256 of this complete Markdown document and its deterministic source projection.